So you want my opinion?
The Bengals cut down to 53 players on Saturday. At the request of some readers who might not realize my primary responsibility is to write for the newspaper product, here are my views on the personnel moves and some related issues:
-- More moves will occur, maybe as many as three or four, before the opener Sept. 10. If a speed running back becomes available (keep your eyes focused on New Orleans) and a linebacker, if not a kicker, the Bengals will strike.
-- Departed Doug Johnson has been voted one of the least popular teammates in the NFL. He also wasn't very good. He threw two interceptions -- all his fault -- in the directions of Chad Johnson and T.J. Houshmandzadeh on Friday night. They're pretty good. No blaming Bennie Brazell for cutting the wrong direction.
-- I like Ryan Fitzpatrick, acquired in the trade from St. Louis. But the Bengals are in bad shape, even with Fitzpatrick, behind Carson Palmer. I still question the decision to draft Jeff Rowe in the fifth round and invest in him for the relative long term. I think the Bengals were unwisely cheap in not trying to bring back Anthony Wright.
-- But, hey, name me a backup quarterback who wouldn't be a major step down from Palmer?
-- Mike Brown and his daughter, Katie Blackburn, both did their undergraduate work at Dartmouth College. As Ivy Leaguers, for the time being, they now have a quarterback from Harvard (Fitzpatrick) and a tight end from Yale (Nate Lawrie).
-- Why did the Bengals keep defensive end Frostee Rucker? He is injury-prone. And based on his track record of legal problems, he has the potential to drag the organization through the mud once again. Reports are Rucker will miss the opener because of a league-mandated suspension.
-- The Bengals did do a good job of cutting ties with another potential off-field troublemaker in wide receiver Reggie McNeal. On the field, McNeal did not do much with his chance to win the No. 4 receiver job.
-- You can never have too many Samoans on your roster. Defensive linemen Domata Peko and Jonathan Fanene stuck as two of the eight. A third Samoan, Matt Toeaina, will hopefully clear waivers and be signed to the Bengals practice squad. These are guys who will only do you proud as an organization. They work exceptionally hard and produce.
-- If Fanene can stay healthy and on the field, he will make plays. For his sake, I hope his hamstring problems are behind him.
-- The Bengals are taking a roster gamble by keeping three players on the 53 who won't be able to play until October -- safety Ethan Kilmer (knee), linebacker Rashad Jeanty (lower leg) and wide receiver Antonio Chatman (hamstring). Coach Marvin Lewis doesn't have much wiggle room getting down to 45 players to dress on Sunday.
-- Tight end Daniel Coats could be the steal of the rookie free agent class. Credit goes to Bengals tight ends coach Jonathan Hayes for spotting him. Coats could be a big-time receiver, though he didn't look too smooth in dropping a couple of balls against the Colts.
-- There were hints even back in June that linebacker Ed Hartwell wouldn't be here opening day, but his release was still a surprise.
-- Heading into the start of my eighth season on the Bengals/NFL beat, I see health a major difference between winning and losing. If you can keep all or most of your best players healthy and avoid a glut of injuries in one position, you have a chance to win.
-- I am a beat reporter, so criticism that I should do more opinion don't bother me. My first and most important job is to report the news for the newspaper version of our product. Then it's the Web product. Then it's this blog.
-- In radio interviews, when the topic of the Bengals' troublemaking players come up, I also try to point out that there are a lot of people in the locker room who would make ideal neighbors. Tops among them are Palmer and defensive tackle John Thornton. It didn't surprise me one bit that their teammates voted them as season-long captains.
-- I liked watching punter Kyle Larson kick extra points Friday night in the conventional, straight-forward manner. I'm old enough to remember the tail end of George Blanda's career and the square-toed high-top kicking shoe he wore. I also remember former Saints kicker Tom Dempsey, who was born with a partial right foot, and the adapted square-toed cleats he wore. Larson said he had a square-toed kicking shoe when he was younger.
6 Comments:
Mark,
Loved hearing your thoughts on the team as an alternative to Geoff Hobson. I love Geoff, but it's nice to hear a different opinion from another beat writer. You should blog your thoughts more! Keep up the good work! Thanks!
Jon S.
Hopefully, they'll cut Chatman and pick up a speed back. Glad to be rid of Doug Johnson. Get rid of the 3rd QB, if he's playing your screwed anyway.
Mark,
Thank you for providing your insights and opinions on the Bengals cuts. This was the most informative article I have read all pre-season.
I know you see the blog as a 3rd priority but in the era of bengals.com, providing quick opinions and insights is a way to connect with your readers.
Mark,
Hey I liked reading your opinions also, even though I don't think it's your favorite thing to throw out your personal thoughts on the team! But since you are close to the team, it's good to hear your viewpoint.
I was surprised by your Doug Johnson comment...I was watching Channel 19 tonight and I am pretty sure they said Doug Johnson was well liked in the clubouse. Or maybe it was just Carson Palmer who said that. But quite surprising to read the exact opposite about an hour later on this blog.
I wonder how a backup QB becomes unpopular anyway.
I thought Doug Johnson looked terrible though. Good move by the Bengals I think. If Palmer ever goes down I'd rather see them lose with a rookie then Doug Johnson.
On Ed Hartwell...that can't be good news for the Bengals that a guy they signed to be an important backup linebacker, one of the Bengals key offseason signings, is now cut before the season starts!
You hear a lot of people say that the defensive line isn't good. Usually well-deserved criticism, but am I the only fan who thinks the Bengals might have the worst linebackers in the NFL?
Maybe I'm overreacting...but there is no playmaker there, and I often think Landon Johnson, Jeanty, etc. wouldn't start on 90% of NFL teams.
My only hope is that the Bengals defense can't possibly be as bad as it has looked so far.
Mark, thanks for posting your thoughts on the Bengals cuts. I'm a reader who previously expressed frustration about a lack of commentary on this blog. I totally get that you're a beat writer and that as such you have to first and foremost report the facts. But hopefully as the season wears on you'll have more time to spend posting quick hits with your opinion. As another reader pointed out, having a second place to turn (other than Geoff Hobson - and I love reading Hobson) would be great.
I would think your first priority would be to give the consumer what they are looking for. Frankly, if your boss is telling you to write facts only for the printed version only, then your boss isn't quite clear on free market economics. If I may speak for the consumers, we crave opinion and facts from people like you, who have the priveledge to watch practices, and mingle in the locker room with players, talk with coaches and see these kids play. Something few of us can do. Also, as a non-Cincinnati resident, I can't get your printed rag anyway. So I'm not helping your subscription numbers, but I do check this site everyday. I can't help you with your print advertising dollar, but me, and every other non-ohio Bengals fan can help you with your web subscriber tally for electronic advertisers, if of course, you give the consumer what they want so they show up. Just a thought.
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site.
<< Home