*

*
Bengals
Mark Curnutte offers the latest on the Cincinnati Bengals


Mark Curnutte started covering the Bengals and the NFL for The Enquirer in 2000. He previously wrote about urban affairs and other social issues for the Enquirer. He won the prestigious 1994 Unity Award from Lincoln University (Missouri) for "A Polite Silence," a seven-day series about race relations in Greater Cincinnati. He also has worked as an assistant features editor and features writer at The News & Observer in Raleigh, N.C. Curnutte is second vice president and a three-year board member of the Professional Football Writers of America (PFWA). He is a 1984 Miami University graduate.

Powered by Blogger

Thursday, March 01, 2007

10 odds and ends on March 1

Item 1: Brian Simmons' release.

It makes sense from a financial sense. No one will say, but knowing how club vice president Katie Blackburn likes to manage the salary cap, I'd guess the Bengals already have absorbed the entire hit for Simmons' $4.9 million signing bonus from 2002. So the move is more than likely worth the full $3.4 million savings.

But he's a lot to lose. Even though he was hurt with the neck strain and missed five games last season, he was around. Coach Marvin Lewis said Simmons added a "sense of calm." That assessment is accurate. Brian always was even. He competed hard, and the fire to win burned inside him. He was an honest man when talking through reporters to the team's fans. He was thoughtful, and what he might have lacked in Takeo Spikes' soundbite ability, Brian always made up for with substance. He was not always easy to quote because he answers were long. But you walked away from his locker having learned something.

Since coming back from a serious right knee injury suffered in the 2000 opener, Simmons played a lot of football for the Bengals. He played in 79 of a possible 80 games with 78 starts. There's something valuable about a guy who's always there and has the ability to play every Sunday. That attribute is why the Bengals can't really be criticized for trying to bring back defensive end Justin Smith. Just always plays and plays hard on every down.

I know Simmons will be picked up somewhere else. I always was struck, too, by his sense of the passing years. He always knew his time was coming, and he accepted it. He didn't fight it, as much as he simply made the most of the time he had to play.

He'll land somewhere else. Here's hoping he gets another chance to make a playoff run.

Item 2: Free agency.

The Bengals will not be big spenders outside of their own locker room. Look for them to use the salary cap space, as I wrote in the Enquirer this morning, to try to re-sign their own unrestricted free agents -- primarily steady veterans the likes of tight end Reggie Kelly, safety Kevin Kaesviharn and third-down back Kenny Watson, whom is invaluable because of Chris Perry's iffy status.

Item 3: The draft.

Coming through combine leftovers, and with Simmons' release, push linebacker higher on the list of needs. The first two Cincinnati picks, Nos. 18 and 49, could be anywhere on defense, with the possible exception of end, where it tagged Smith and extended Robert Geathers for six years.

Item 4: Odell Thurman.

I'm sure the Bengals are doing everything they can to help the linebacker, who is in alcohol rehab. Odell is a personable young guy, not to make excuses for his poor choices. He has a spark in his personality that translates to the field. He makes big plays. He has a big personality.

Lewis spoke eloquently at the combine about the need and priority to help Thurman the man, not the football player.

But if Lewis and the Bengals can help Odell the man, wow, they could get back one excellent football player.

Item 5: The blog.

The blog is a brave new world for an old-timer like me, who has worked in daily newspapers, well, every day since I was graduated from Miami University in 1984.

Readers won't find everything in this blog that they do on the rest of the Enquirer's Web site. For example, one reader wanted a Simmons' entry/comment. OK, it's up there. But I had a full story this morning in the newspaper, and we posted the news as soon as it was announced Wednesday afternoon, with additional information (salary, contract years remaining, perspective) not provided by the Bengals.

Item 6: Silence is golden rule and Marvin Lewis.

I want my readers to know how much I respect my job. In criticizing Lewis for shutting down his assistants at the combine, I understand that move is his choice. At the same time, then, he criticizes responsible media for trying to read tea leaves and figure it out ourselves.

I like Lewis. I respect his talent. He's extremely bright. But I've told him I won't kiss his butt. I enjoy our professional relationship, which, by definition, is awkward. I like studying his methods and trying to anticipate his next move. A friend from the Baltimore Sun told me, when Lewis was a candidate for the job here, to sharpen my extrapolation skills. My buddy said Lewis likes to work in riddles. I've found that to be true.

He's competitive, and like many other NFL coaches, he views the release of information as hurting his competitive edge. OK. My point in writing that his assistants weren't talking is to let readers know why they weren't being quoted in the newspaper. And, yes, it's frustrating from my perspective.

Item 7: It's not the Cold War, but ...

The job of covering an NFL team is complicated by competing against team employees on team-owned Web sites that are increasingly fed information by the teams themselves. The league controls its own popular Web site and has its own television network. It's banking, I'd say, on viewers/readers not giving a damn or even being aware of the value of getting information from independent sources.

I don't have a journalism degree (English and geography), but in the five journalism classes I took at Miami, I do remember hearing that a "journalist" could not cover his or her employer. That's PR. Or, as a professor once said -- making a Cold War reference later echoed by one of my former Enquirer deputy sports editors -- "it's Tass." (Humor me: Here's an example of fun you can have by writing with a dictionary close by. Tass is an acronym, in Russian, for Telegrafnoe Agentstvo Sovetskogo Soyuza, the Telegraph Agency of the Soviet Union. It was the government agency charged with gathering and distributing (read: controlling) news.

Item 8: So riddle me this.

Lewis' tighter-than-normal secrecy this offseason suggests, too me, that though he could go 8-8 or 9-7 every year and make his boss, Mike Brown, happy, the coach is pushing himself and applying additional pressure internally to get his team back into the playoffs. To his credit, Lewis is not pleased with 8-8 or 9-7. He wants to win 10 games every year.

This team is his. Simmons' release leaves just nine players left from the 2002 team Lewis inherited. There are just two on defense, Smith and Kaesviharn. On offense, the holdovers are Willie Anderson, T.J. Houshmandzadeh, Chad Johnson, Rudi Johnson, Levi Jones, Brad St. Louis and Tony Stewart.

Item 9: Linebackers

The cupboard is bare. Lewis and his regime have not done well in drafting linebackers. You can't help injuries, and we all wish David Pollack well in his possible return to football and, more important, in his quest to have a full and healthy life. But there were questions that he was a reach. Thurman's problems have been well documents. Khalid Abdullah in playing in Canada. Caleb Miller has struggled with injuries and has proven to not be an every-down linebacker. Landon Johnson is steady and productive but not a big playmaker. Ahmad Brooks might have been forced upon Lewis by Mike Brown.

Lewis can't swing and miss this year when picking a linebacker.

Item 10: Lyric of the day

The song "Simple Twist of Fate" from Bob Dylan's great "Blood on the Tracks" record is going through my head these days. Maybe it's leftover from the nerve endings-exposed experience of seeing my parents' headstones side by side for the first time.

"People tell me it's a sin
To know and feel too much within."

My apologies: To write great as an adjective modifying "Blood on the Tracks" is a redundancy.


8 Comments:

at 3/01/2007 1:57 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mark-

I guess I can see the Simmons cut, but if they need cap room, what about Sam Adams? Clearly his knee problems were related to reporting at 400+ lbs and in no shape to play.

Maybe the math doesn't work for his contract, but I don't anticipate much in the way of future contribution from him.

 
at 3/01/2007 3:28 PM Blogger Laura said...

So who do you think the Bengals will draft? Will they go with Posluzny from Penn? I know he's respected as one of the best athletes in this draft class.

 
at 3/01/2007 11:47 PM Blogger Antonio said...

Mark,
Thanks for the amazing post. It was certainly not 'Idiot Wind'.

 
at 3/02/2007 10:37 AM Anonymous Anonymous said...

I am an avid follower of the NFL Draft. I saw nothing about Pollack being a reach. In fact, I heard teams lamenting that they didn't get him and thought he would be a very good LB. I think the Ravens picking 5 picks later were one of those teams.

Any pick can be considered a reach. Remember how Levi Jones was a terrible reach? In other words, the few people who were lucky enough to say Pollack was picked too early now can crow about their foresight thanks to his injury.

 
at 3/02/2007 10:51 AM Anonymous Anonymous said...

And if you look at that draft, the guys right after Pollack were:

Erasmus James - 4 career sacks and out most of last year on IR.
Marcus Spears - 2.5 career sacks
Luis Castillo - Has been great for San Diego (as a DT) but had questions
about him due to steroid use to overcome an injury

That is it for players that could have been picked for a comparable
position to Pollack. Pollack, by the way, had 4.5 sacks his rookie
year. And yes, productivity cannot be based on just sacks, but it is
hard to quantify.

I say Pollack has been better than the two guys the Bengals could
have selected instead. But yes, it does hurt that the top of the 2005
draft didn't contribute last year - Pollack and Thurman.

 
at 3/02/2007 1:29 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

Does anybody else want mark Cannutte to stop crying about his lack of access and or information? mark wants marvin to respect his position but goes on sports talk radio shows with lance mccalister and bashes the coach.

 
at 3/02/2007 2:05 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

If you want to get the dirt in the NFL anymore, you can forget about the league/coaches; it comes from the agents.

 
at 3/03/2007 12:48 AM Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mark

First, you are too critical of yourself and you don't owe anyone explanations. Marvin Lewis may have improved this football program, but the reality is that he has had one winning season in his 4 years of coaching and has had two opportunities to go to the playoffs by winning the last game of the season and has failed both times. He is unusually sensitive to critism and tries to bully the media by being arrogant and condesceding and then expects them to back off. If it's any consolation, he appears to give Hobson the same treatment.

Second, your opportunity to differentiate yourself is in your ability to critically assess the Bengals for the serious fan (like you've just done in your blog). That is what people want to read. The Bengals have done a very poor job of drafting/developing linebackers and they now have serious problems on defense. That won't be written on Bengals.com. You have the opportuntity to offer the fans true (rather than tainted) insight.

You do a great job. Keep digging!!!

 
Post a Comment*

* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.

By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site.

<< Home


Blogs


Jim Borgman
Today at the Forum
Paul Daugherty
Politics Extra
N. Ky. Politics
Pop culture review
Cincytainment
Who's News
Television
Roller Derby Diva
Art
CinStages Buzz....
The Foodie Report
cincyMOMS
Classical music
John Fay's Reds Insider
Bengals
High school sports
NCAA
UC Sports
CiN Weekly staff
Soundcheck

Advertisement